Hindu-Muslim Polemics in Colonial India: A Study of Thanā Allah Amritsari (1868 -1948 C.E.)

Shaista Rasool



The nineteenth century was a time of tremendous change for Islamic intellectual traditions in British India in an era of colonialism, the decline of traditional authority, and the transformations of modernity. It was the period when the basis of Islam was attacked many times and efforts were made to create misconceptions in its teachings. In spite of these challenges, Muslim scholars, theologians, and intellectuals proved to be particularly creative in this period, laying the foundations for the rethinking and reconfiguration of Islamic intellectual traditions in a modern context. Thanā Allah Amritsari was one of the great scholars of subcontinent who spent his whole life in shielding the cause of Islam with his tongue and pen. He frequently held debates both oral and written with different religious groups, both Muslims and non-Muslims. He challenged the Christians, Ārya Samājists, Qadyanis, Sufi brotherhoods and the Shi’a scholars alike. When the Hindu creed attached Islam and its pristine doctrines in its new form of Ārya Samāj, he not only defended Islam with his tongue and pen but also exposed the reality of Hindu creed and analysed critically the literature produced by its proponents. This paper discusses in detail the method of polemical discourse of Thana Allah Amritsari with Ārya Samāj and its proponents. The paper provides an analysis of important books of Thanā Allah Amritsari written in response to Hinduism in general and Ārya Samāj in particular.

Key words: Thanā Allah Amritsari, Ārya Samāj, Hinduism, Islam, India.


Thanā Allah Amritsari, Ārya Samāj, Hinduism, IslamIndia

Full Text:




Ahmad, Aziz, Studies in the Islamic Culture in the Indian Environment. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1964.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Ahl al-Ḥadīth, 10th August 1906.

Amritsari, Thana Allah, Ahl al-Ḥadīth, 17th Nov 1920.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Ahl al-Ḥadīth, 1st December, 1905.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Haq Prakāsh Ba Jawāb Satyārath Prakāsh. Lahore: Numani Kutub Khana, 2001.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Ḥudūth Ved, Lahore: Barqi Matbaʾa Roz, 1982.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Muhammad Rīshi. Lahore: Barqi Matbaʾa Roz, 1923.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Muqaddas Rasūl ba Jawāb Rangīla Rasūl. UP: Maktabah al-Fahīm, 2014.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Nūr Tawhīd. Amritsar: Sanai Barqi Press, 1938.

Amritsari, Thanā Allah, Tafsīr Thanāʾi. Lahore: Maktabah Qudūsiyyah, 2002.

Bashir Ahmad Khan “The polemical History of Twentieth Century Punjab A Case Study of Sona Ullah Amritsari” in Challenges to Religions and Islam; A study of Muslim Movements, Personalities Issues and Trends, ed. Hamid Naseem Rafiabadi, (New Delhi: Sarup and Sons, 2007), 984.

Chand, Tara, History of Freedom Movement in India. Government of India: Publications Division Ministry of Information and Broadcasting, 1967.

Farquhar, J.N, Modern Religious Movements in India. New York: The Macmillan Company, 1915.

Irāqī, Abdul Rashīd, Tazkirah Abul Wafā. Islamabad: Nadwatul Muḥadīthīn, 1984.

Jones, W Kenneth, Ārya Dharm Hindu Consciousness in 19th- Century Punjab. London: University of California Press, 1976.

Mc Cully T, Bruce, English Education and the Origins of Indian Nationalism. New York, 1940

Mubarakpūri, Maulana Safi al-Rahman, Fitnah Qādyāniyat aur Thana Allah Amritsari, Lahore: Maktabah Muhammadiyah, 2007.

Muḥammad, Fazl al-Rahmān bin Miyān, Raʹīsul Manāzirin̄ Shaykh al-Islam Hazrat Maulānā Thanā Allah Amritsari. Lahore: Dār al-Ulūm Salafiyyah, 1947.

Noshahrwi, Imam Khan, Nuqūsh-i-Abul Wafa. Lahore: Islami Academy, 1998.

Punjab Administration Report, 1927-28.

Qureshi, Ishtiaq Husain, Ulema in Politics. Delhi: Renaissance Publishing House, 1985.

Rai, Lajpat, The Ārya Samāj. New York: Longmans Green and Co. 1915.

Skaff, Joseph, “Christian Missionary Attitude towards Islam in India” (Unpublished M.A. Thesis, Montreal: McGill University, 1971), 75

Sohadri, ‘Abd al-Majīd Khādim, Sīrat Thanāʾi. Lahore: Maktabah Qudūsiyyah, 1989.

The Partab, July, 1924.

Thursby, Gene R, Hindu Muslim Relation in British India: A study of Controversy, Conflict and Communal Movements in Northern India 1923-1928, Leiden: Brill, 1975.

Wakīl Amritsar, September 6, 1924.


  • There are currently no refbacks.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License.